Worst Vinyl Plank Flooring Brands: Avoid These 8 for a Better Floor!

Are you tired of spending your hard-earned money on flooring that is a total disaster? Have you ever experienced the disappointment of watching your vinyl plank flooring quickly deteriorate, leaving your home worn-out and shabby? Well, you’re not alone! Many homeowners have fallen victim to the false promises of subpar vinyl plank brands that don’t deliver. In this blog post, we’ll dive deep into the world of vinyl plank flooring to uncover the 8 worst Vinyl plank flooring brands you should steer clear of at all costs. So, buckle up, and let’s explore these flooring nightmares you should avoid!

1. Shaw Prodigy HDR Plus Floorte Elite Vinyl Flooring

Shaw’s Prodigy HDR Plus Floorte Elite Vinyl Flooring boasts a reputation for high-quality products, but unfortunately, this specific line doesn’t quite live up to its name. Despite being marketed as a durable and waterproof option, many homeowners have reported premature wear and tear issues. The top layer may scratch easily, leaving unsightly marks that are challenging to repair. Additionally, the floor’s surface can discolor over time, especially in areas exposed to sunlight. Installation might be troublesome due to problems with the locking mechanism, leading to misaligned planks and visible gaps.

2. MSI Rutledge Luxury Vinyl Flooring

MSI is a respected brand known for its wide range of options, but the Rutledge Luxury Vinyl Flooring has disappointed some customers. While initial impressions might be positive, with its natural-looking design and texture, it falls short regarding long-term durability. Many users have reported issues with the flooring showing signs of wear and tear, even with minimal foot traffic. Scratches and dents may become evident, detracting from the floor’s overall appeal. Additionally, some homeowners have experienced problems with the planks warping or cupping, which can be costly and frustrating.

3. NeuType Luxury Vinyl Flooring Plank

NeuType is a lesser-known brand that has struggled to gain traction in the vinyl plank flooring market. Their Luxury Vinyl Flooring Plank has received mixed reviews, with several customers expressing dissatisfaction with its performance. One of the most common complaints is its susceptibility to scratching and chipping, making it less than ideal for households with pets or active families. Despite the marketing claims, this flooring might not be as waterproof as advertised, as some users have noticed swelling or damage after exposure to water. Moreover, the adhesive used in the planks’ installation has been reported to have a strong and unpleasant odor, making the installation process less enjoyable.

4. MIRUO SPC Vinyl Plank Flooring

MIRUO’s SPC Vinyl Plank Flooring is marketed as a high-quality, premium option but may need to live up to its promises. While the Stone Plastic Composite (SPC) core is intended to provide enhanced stability and durability, some customers have experienced issues with the planks peeling or separating over time. The floor’s surface can be susceptible to fading, especially in areas exposed to direct sunlight, leading to a patchy and unappealing appearance. The locking system may also not hold up well, leading to gaps between the planks and potential water infiltration.

5. Coretec Floor

Coretec is a well-established brand that has garnered praise for its innovation in the flooring industry. However, their vinyl plank flooring line has faced criticism in recent times. While the initial installation might be straightforward and hassle-free, some users have reported problems with the planks warping or cupping after some time. These issues could be due to manufacturing defects or improper installation, but regardless, it is a concern for potential buyers. Furthermore, the floor’s surface can be susceptible to scratches, diminishing its visual appeal over time. It’s essential to carefully assess your options and consider other brands with better reputations for durability.

6. Nakan Signature From Flooret

Flooret’s Nakan Signature line might have an appealing design, but some customers have encountered significant challenges with this vinyl plank flooring. The locking mechanism has been a primary concern, as it may not hold the planks securely in place, resulting in uneven surfaces and visible gaps. This can be particularly problematic in high-traffic areas, where the risk of tripping or catching debris between the planks increases. Additionally, the floor’s surface might be prone to scratching, making it less than ideal for busy households or those with pets. It’s essential to consider other options that offer better quality and performance.

7. Armstrong Rigid Core Flooring

Armstrong has been a household name in the flooring industry for many years, but their Rigid Core Flooring has received mixed reviews. While the rigid core technology is intended to provide added stability and resistance to dents, some users have reported issues with the planks showing signs of wear and tear relatively quickly. Scratches and dents may become noticeable, affecting the floor’s overall appearance. Moreover, this flooring might not be the best option for areas with temperature fluctuations, as some users have observed expansion and contraction issues, leading to gaps between the planks over time. It’s crucial to weigh the pros and cons before committing to Armstrong’s Rigid Core Flooring.

8. ROSEROSA Peel And Stick Vinyl Flooring

Roserosa’s Peel and Stick Vinyl Flooring is convenient and cost-effective. Still, it might not provide the durability and longevity you expect from traditional vinyl plank flooring. While the ease of installation is undoubtedly a plus, some users have found that the adhesive used in these planks can lose its grip over time, causing the edges to curl or the entire plank to lift. This leads to an uneven and unattractive floor and creates a potential tripping hazard. Moreover, the floor’s surface may be prone to scratching and damage, especially in areas with heavy foot traffic. For a more reliable and long-lasting solution, it’s best to explore other brands with a better track record of performance.

Key Factors to Keep in Mind When Selecting a Vinyl Plank Flooring Brand

  • Durability and Wear Resistance: When selecting a vinyl plank flooring brand, prioritize those that offer exceptional durability and wear resistance. Look for products with scratch-resistant surfaces and strong protective layers to ensure your flooring withstands the test of time, especially in high-traffic areas.
  • Waterproof and Moisture Resistance: A reliable vinyl plank flooring brand should boast excellent waterproof and moisture-resistant properties. This feature is crucial, especially in bathrooms and kitchens, where spills and humidity are common. Opt for brands with tight locking mechanisms to prevent water infiltration between the planks.
  • Installation and Locking Mechanism: The ease of installation can significantly impact your overall experience with vinyl plank flooring. Look for brands with user-friendly installation systems, like click-lock mechanisms, that ensure a secure fit and reduce the risk of gaps or misaligned planks.
  • Warranty and Customer Reviews: Always check the warranty provided by the vinyl plank flooring brand. A reliable manufacturer will offer a substantial warranty, indicating their confidence in the product’s quality. Additionally, read customer reviews to gain insights into real-world experiences with the flooring brand.
  • Brand Reputation and Quality Control: Research the brand’s reputation and history in the flooring industry. Brands with a long-standing positive reputation for quality are more likely to produce reliable vinyl plank flooring options. Check if they have a robust quality control process to minimize the chances of manufacturing defects.


When choosing the right vinyl plank flooring for your home, it is crucial to be cautious and avoid the worst brands. 

Shaw Prodigy HDR Plus Floorte Elite, MSI Rutledge Luxury Vinyl Flooring, NeuType Luxury Vinyl Flooring Plank, MIRUO SPC Vinyl Plank Flooring, Coretec Floor, Nakan Signature From Flooret, Armstrong Rigid Core Flooring, and ROSEROSA Peel And Stick Vinyl Flooring have all demonstrated significant issues with durability, water resistance, installation, and overall quality. 

By considering key factors and doing thorough research on reputable brands, you can ensure that your vinyl plank flooring investment will withstand the test of time and provide a beautiful, reliable, and long-lasting solution for your home.


How can the quality of a vinyl floor be determined?

The quality of a vinyl floor can be determined by examining its wear layer thickness, the type of core material (SPC or WPC), and its overall construction. High-quality vinyl floors typically have a thick wear layer, a sturdy core, and realistic textures that mimic natural materials.

Which type of vinyl flooring is the most durable?

SPC (Stone Plastic Composite) is considered the most durable among vinyl flooring types. SPC vinyl is denser and more rigid than WPC (Wood Plastic Composite) vinyl, making it highly resistant to impacts, dents, and heavy foot traffic.

What vinyl brand would you recommend?

I don’t have preferences for an AI language model, but some well-regarded vinyl flooring brands include Mohawk, Shaw, Armstrong, Mannington, and Karndean. However, it’s essential to research each brand’s specific product lines and read customer reviews to find the best fit for your needs.

What issues arise during vinyl plank flooring installation?

Common issues during vinyl plank flooring installation include misalignment and gaps between planks, difficulty with the locking mechanism, adhesive failures (for peel-and-stick varieties), and difficulty cutting planks accurately around corners and obstacles. Proper preparation, following manufacturer guidelines, and using the right tools can help mitigate these problems.

Table of Contents

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on pinterest
Get Free Design & Quote

    Explore our Best Vinyl Flooring Collection
    Scroll to Top